In situ conditions affecting the ductility capacity of lightly reinforced concrete wall structures in the Canterbury earthquake sequence
Following the 2010-2011 Canterbury (New Zealand) earthquake sequence, lightly reinforced wall structures in the Christchurch central business district were observed to form undesirable crack patterns in the plastic hinge region, while yield penetration either side of cracks and into development zones was less than predicted using empirical expressions. To some extent this structural behaviour was unexpected and has therefore demonstrated that there may be less confidence in the seismic performance of conventionally designed reinforced concrete (RC) structures than previously anticipated. This paper provides an observation-based comparison between the behaviour of RC structural components in laboratory testing and the unexpected structural behaviour of some case study buildings in Christchurch that formed concentrated inelastic deformations. The unexpected behaviour and poor overall seismic performance of ‘real’ buildings (compared to the behaviour of laboratory test specimens) was due to the localization of peak inelastic strains, which in some cases has arguably led to: (i) significantly less ductility capacity; (ii) less hysteretic energy dissipation; and (iii) the fracture of the longitudinal reinforcement. These observations have raised concerns about whether lightly reinforced wall structures can satisfy the performance objective of “Life Safety” at the Ultimate Limit State. The significance of these issues and potential consequences has prompted a review of potential problems with the testing conditions and procedures that are commonly used in seismic experimentations on RC structures. This paper attempts to revisit the principles of RC mechanics, in particular, the influence of loading history, concrete tensile strength, and the quantity of longitudinal reinforcement on the performance of real RC structures. Consideration of these issues in future research on the seismic performance of RC might improve the current confidence levels in newly designed conventional RC structures.
Kam WY, Pampanin S and Elwood K. (2011). “Seismic Performance of Reinforced Concrete Buildings in the 22 February Christchurch (Lyttelton) Earthquake”. Bulletin of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering; 44(4): 239-278. http://www.nzsee.org.nz/db-/Special-Issue/44(4)0239.pdf DOI: https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.44.4.239-278
Bull DK (2012). “The Performance of Concrete Structures in the Canterbury Earthquakes: Lessons for Concrete Buildings”. Structural Engineers Association of California (SEAOC) Convention, Santa Fe, NM.
Canterbury Earthquakes Royal Commission, CERC (2012). “Final report: Volume 2 - The performance of Christchurch CBD Buildings”. http://canterbury.royal-commission.govt.nz/Final-Report---Volumes-1-2-and-3
Fenwick RC (2013). “Aspects of the Seismic Performance of Concrete Buildings”. Conference proceedings of the New Zealand Concrete Society, Queenstown, New Zealand.
Fenwick RC and Dhakal RP (2007a). “Material Strain Limits for Seismic Design of Concrete Structures”. SESOC Journal, 20(1): 14-28.
Standards New Zealand. (2006). “NZS3101: Parts 1 and 2 Concrete Structures Standard-New Zealand”. Standards New Zealand, Wellington.
Walker AF (2007). “Assessment of Material Strain Limits for Defining Different Forms of Plastic Hinge Region in Concrete Structures”. Master of Engineering Thesis, University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Beyer K, Dazio A and Priestley MJN (2008). “Quasi-Static Cyclic Tests of Two U-shaped Reinforced Concrete Walls”. Journal of Earthquake Engineering, 12:7, 1023-1053. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13632460802003272 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13632460802003272
Priestley MJN and Park R (1984). “Strength and Ductility of Bridge Substructures”. RRU Bulletin 71, National Roads Board, Wellington, New Zealand.
NZSEE (2006). “Assessment and Improvement of the Structural Performance of Buildings in Earthquakes”. Recommendations of a Study Group of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering. http://www.nzsee-.org.nz/db/PUBS/2006_AISPBE_Corrigenda_3%20.pdf
Fenwick RC and Dhakal RP (2007b). “Material Strains and Relevance to Seismic Design”. SESOC Journal, 20(1): 5-12.
Paulay T and Priestley MJN (1992). “Seismic Design of Reinforced Concrete and Masonry Buildings”. John Wiley & Son, Inc., New York, United States of America. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470172841
Priestley MJN, Kowalsky MJ and Calvi GM (2007). “Displacement-Based Seismic Design of Structures”. IUSS PRESS, Pavia, Italy.
Liddell D, Ingham JM and Davidson BJ (2000). “Influence of Loading History on Ultimate Displacement of Concrete Structures”. Report No. 597, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand.
Eligehausen R, Popov EP and Bertero VV (1983). “Local Bond Stress-slip Relationships of Deformed Bars under Generalized Excitations”. Report UCB/EERC-83/23, University of California, Berkeley. http://nisee.berkeley-.edu/documents/EERC/EERC-83-23.pdf
Shima H, Chou LL and Okamura H (1987). “Micro and Macro Models for Bond in Reinforced Concrete”. Reprinted from Journal of the Faculty of Engineering, The University of Tokyo, 39(2).
Bonacci JF (1994a). “Bar Yield Penetration in Monotonically Loaded Anchorages”. Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE, 120(3), 965-986. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9445(1994)120:3(965)
Mayer U and Eligehausen R (1998). “Bond Behaviour of Ribbed Bars at Inelastic Steel Strains.” 2nd International Ph.D. Symposium in Civil Engineering, Budapest.
Lowes LN, Moehle JP and Govindjee S (2004). “Concrete-Steel Bond Model for use in Finite Element Modelling of Reinforced Concrete Structures”. ACI Structural Journal, 101(4), 501-511. http://dx.doi.org/10.-14359/13336
Fédération Internationale du Béton, fib (2012). “Model Code 2010 - Final Draft, Volume 2”. FIB Bulletin No. 66, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Soleymani Ashtiani M, Dhakal RP and Scott AN (2013). “Post-Yield Bond Behaviour of Deformed Bars in High-Strength Self-compacting Concrete”. Construction and Building Materials, 44, 236-248. http://dx.doi.org/-10.1016/j.con-buildmat.2013.02.072
Dickson AR (1986). “The Response of Reinforced Concrete Slabs to Concentrated Loading”. Report No. 408, University of Auckland, New Zealand.
Comite' Euro-internationale du beton, CEB-FIP (1993). “The Model Code 1990: Design code”. London: T. Telford; 1993.
Standards New Zealand. (1995). “NZS3101: Concrete Structures Standard-New Zealand”. Standards New Zealand, Wellington.
Smith PC and Devine J (2012a). “Independent Assessment of Earthquake Performance of Craig’s Investment Partners House – 90 Armagh Street”. Prepared for the Canterbury Earthquakes Royal Commission. http://canterbury.royal-commission.govt.nz/documents-by-key/20120229.3509
Smith PC and Devine J (2012b). “Independent Assessment of Earthquake Performance of Inland Revenue Department Building – 224 Cashell Street”. Prepared for the Canterbury Earthquakes Royal Commission. http://canterbury.royal-commission.govt.nz/documents-by-key/20120227.3340
Leon RT and Deierlein GG (1996). “Considerations for the use of Quasi-Static Testing”. Earthquake Spectra, 12, 87-109. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1193/1.1585869
Krawinkler H (2009). “Loading Histories for Cyclic Tests in Support of Performance Assessment of Structural Components”. The 3rd International Conference on Advances in Experimental Structural Engineering, October 15-16, San Francisco, CA.
Akguzel U and Pampanin S (2010). “Effects of Variation of Axial Load and Bidirectional Loading on Seismic Performance of GFRP Retrofitted Reinforced Concrete Exterior Beam-Column Joints”. Journal of Composites for Construction 14(1): 94-104. http://dx.doi.org/10.1061/-(ASCE)10900268(2010)14:1(94)
Park R (1989). “Evaluation of Ductility of Structures and Structural Assemblages from Laboratory Testing.” Bulletin of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering. 22(3), 155-166. http://www.nzsee.org.nz/db/Bulletin/- Archive/22(3)0155.pdf DOI: https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.22.3.155-166
FEMA-461 (2007). “Interim Protocols for Determining Seismic Performance Characteristics of Structural and Non-structural Components Through Laboratory Testing”. Prepared by Applied Technology Council (ATC) for Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), Redwood City, California.
Vos E and Reinhardt HW (1982). “Influence of Loading Rate on Bond Behaviour of Reinforcing Steel and Prestressing Strands”. Materials and Structures. RILEM 15(85), 3-10. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02473553
Chung L and Shah SP (1989). “Effect of Loading Rate on Anchorage Bond and Beam-Column Joints.” ACI Structural Journal, 86(2), 132-142. http://dx.doi.org/10.14359/2628 DOI: https://doi.org/10.14359/2628
Phan V, Saiidi MS, Anderson J and Ghasemi H (2007). “Near-Fault Ground Motion Effect on Reinforced Concrete Bridge Columns”. Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE, 133(7), 982-989. http://dx.doi.org-/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9445(2007)133:7(982) DOI: https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9445(2007)133:7(982)
Choi H, Saiidi MS, Somerville P and El-Azazy S (2010). “Experimental Study of Reinforced Concrete Bridge Columns Subjected to Near-Fault Ground Motions”. ACI Structural Journal, 107(1), 3-12. http://dx.doi.org/10.14359/51663383 DOI: https://doi.org/10.14359/51663383
Bennett A, Sharpe RD, and Stannard MC (2014). “Prioritising Research into the Seismic Performance of Reinforced Concrete.” Conference Proceedings of the New Zealand Society of Earthquake Engineering, Auckland. http://db.nzsee.org.nz/2014/oral/38_Bennett.pdf
Cuevas A and Pampanin S (2015). “Effect of Strain-Rate and Material Characteristics on the Seismic Residual Capacity of Reinforced Concrete Plastic Hinges: Numerical Investigation.” Conference proceedings of the New Zealand Society of Earthquake Engineering, Rotorua.
Holmes Solutions (2011). “Materials Testing in Buildings of Interest: Prepared for the Canterbury Earthquakes Royal Commission.” November 2011, Christchurch, New Zealand. http://canterbury.royalcommission.govt.nz/docu-ments-by-key/20111129.1351
Henry RS (2013). “Assessment of Minimum Vertical Reinforcement Limits for RC walls.” Bulletin of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering. 46(2), 88-96. http://www.nzsee.org.nz/db/Bulletin/Current/46(2)00-88.pdf DOI: https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.46.2.88-96
Lu Y, Henry RS and Ma QT (2014). “Numerical Modelling and Testing of Concrete Walls with Minimum Vertical Reinforcement”. Conference proceedings of the New Zealand Society of Earthquake Engineering, Auckland. http://db.nzsee.org.nz/2014/oral/23_Lu.pdf
Henry RS, Lu Y and Ingham JM (2014). “Experimental Testing and Modelling to Address the Performance of RC Walls during the 2010/2011 Canterbury Earthquakes”. Proceedings of the 10th National Conference in Earthquake Engineering, Earthquake Engineering Research Institute, Anchorage, AK.
Fenwick RC and Sue CFC (1982). “The Influence of Water Gain upon the Tensile Strength of Concrete”. Magazine of Concrete Research, 34(120): 139-145. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1680/macr.19188.8.131.52
SESOC (2011). “Preliminary Observations from Christchurch Earthquakes”. Prepared for the Canterbury Earthquakes Royal Commission. http://canterbury.royal-commission.govt.nz/documents-by-key/20111205.1533
Soleymani Ashtiani M, Dhakal RP and Scott, AN (2014). “Seismic Performance of High-Strength Self-Compacting Concrete in Reinforced Concrete Beam-Column Joints.” Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE, 140(5), 04014002. http://dx.doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)ST.1943-541X.0000973 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)ST.1943-541X.0000973
SESOC (2012). “Practice note - Design of Conventional Structural Systems Following Canterbury Earthquakes”. Prepared for the Canterbury Earthquakes Royal Commission. http://canterbury.royalcommission.govt.nz/- documents-by-key/20111221.1908
Sritharan S, Beyer K, Henry RS, Chai YH, Kowalsky MJ and Bull DK (2014). “Understanding Poor Seismic Performance of Concrete Walls and Design Implications”. Earthquake Spectra, 30(1), 307-334. http://dx.doi.org/10.1193/021713EQS036M DOI: https://doi.org/10.1193/021713EQS036M
Davey RA and Blaikie EL (2005). “On the Flexural Ductility of very Lightly Reinforced Concrete Sections”. Conference proceedings of the New Zealand Society of Earthquake Engineering, Taupo. http://www.nzsee.org.nz-/db/2005/-Paper15.pdf
Standards New Zealand (2001). “NZS4671: Steel Reinforcing Materials Standard-New Zealand.” Standards New Zealand, Wellington.
Davies-Colley S, Kleinjan B, Bull DK and Morris GJ (2015). “Review of the Material and Flexural Overstrength Factors for Grade 300E Reinforcing Steel used in New Zealand”. Conference proceedings of the New Zealand Society of Earthquake Engineering, Rotorua, New Zealand.
Morris GJ, Bull DK and Bradley BA, (2015). “Monotonic and Cyclic Bond Behaviour of Deformed Bars in Reinforced Concrete Structures”. Conference proceedings of the New Zealand Society of Earthquake Engineering, April 2015, Rotorua, New Zealand.
Lau DBH (2007). “Influence of Precast Prestressed Flooring on Seismic Performance of Reinforced Concrete Perimeter Frame Buildings”. Doctor of Philosophy Thesis, University of Auckland, New Zealand.
Malcolm RC, Bull DK, Henry RS and Ingham JM (2014). “The Effects of Axial Restraint in Reinforced Concrete Coupling Beams.” Proceedings of the New Zealand Concrete Industry Conference, Taupo.
Naish D, Fry JA, Klemencic R and Wallace J (2009). “Experimental Evaluation and Analytical Modeling of ACI 318-05/08 Reinforced Concrete Coupling Beams Subjected to Reversed Cyclic Loading”. UCLA/SGEL Report-2009/06, University of California, Los Angeles.
Williams MS and Sexsmith RG (1995). “Seismic Damage Indices for Concrete Structures: A State-of-the-art Review”. Earthquake Spectra, 11(2), 319-349. http://dx.doi.org/10.1193/1.1585817 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1193/1.1585817
Copyright (c) 2015 Gareth J. Morris, Desmond K. Bull, Brendon A. Bradley
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.