To cordon or not to cordon: The inherent complexities of post-earthquake cordoning learned from Christchurch and Wellington experiences

  • Shakti Shrestha University of Otago, Dunedin
  • Caroline Orchiston University of Otago, Dunedin
  • Kenneth Elwood University of Auckland, NZ
  • David Johnston Massey University, Wellington
  • Julia Becker Massey University, Wellington

Abstract

The use of post-earthquake cordons as a tool to support emergency managers after an event has been documented around the world. However, there is limited research that attempts to understand the inherent complexities of cordoning once applied, particularly the longer-term impacts and consequences. This research aims to fill the gap by providing a detailed understanding of cordons, their management, and the implications of cordoning in a post-earthquake environment. We use a qualitative method to understand cordons through case studies of two cities where cordons were used at different temporal and spatial scales: Christchurch (M6.3, February 2011) and Wellington (M7.8 in Kaikōura, November 2016), New Zealand. Data was collected through 21 key informant interviews obtained through purposive and snowball sampling of participants who were directly or indirectly involved in a decision-making role and/or had influence in relation to the cordoning process. The participants were from varying backgrounds and roles i.e. emergency managers, council members, business representatives, insurance representatives, police, and communication managers. We find that cordons are used primarily as a tool to control access for the purpose of life safety and security, but cordons can also be adapted to support recovery. Broadly, our analysis suggests two key aspects, ‘decision-making’ and ‘operations and management’, which overlap and interact as part of a complex system. The underlying complexity arises in large part due to the multitude of sectors affected by cordons: economics, law, politics, governance, evacuation, civil liberties, available resources etc. The complexity further increases as the duration of cordoning is extended.

References

Pascaline W and Rowena H (2018). “Economic Losses, Poverty and Disaster 1998-2017”. Report for the United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction, Geneva, and Center for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters, Brussels, 33 pp. https://doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.35610.08643

Contreras D, Forino G and Blaschke T (2018). "Measuring the progress of a recovery process after an earthquake: The case of L’aquila, Italy". International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 28: 450–464. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijdrr.2017.09.048

Chang SE, Taylor JE, Elwood KJ, Seville E, Brunsdon D and Gartner M (2014). "Urban disaster recovery in Christchurch: The central business district cordon and other critical decisions". Earthquake Spectra, 30(1): 513–532. https://doi.org/10.1193/022413EQS050M

Schwab Ji, Topping KC, Eadie CC, Deyle RE and Smith RA (1998). "Planning for Post-Disaster Recovery and Reconstruction". 483/484, APA, Washington, 352 pp. https://nehrpsearch.nist.gov/static/files/FEMA/PB2003104335.pdf

MCDEM (2015). "Emergency Movement Control". Ministry of Civil Defence and Emergency Management, Wellington, 50 pp. https://www.civildefence.govt.nz/assets/Uploads/logistics-dgl/DGL-18-15-Emergency-Movement-Control-PDF.pdf

Oxford (2010). "Oxford Dictionary of English" Third Edition. Editor: Stevenson A, Oxford University Press, 2069 pp. https://www.lexico.com/definition/cordon

MCCLL (2005). "Cordon and Search Tactics, Techniques and Procedure". Marine Corps Center for Lessons Learned, Virginia, 14 pp. https://info.publicintelligence.net/MCCLL-CordonSearch.pdf

IFE (2019). "Control Measure - Establish Appropriate Cordon". Institution of Fire Engineers, Leicester, 110 pp. https://www.ife.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/350-The-Foundation-for-Incident-Command-109-pages.pdf

Alexander D (2013). "An evaluation of medium-term recovery processes after the 6 April 2009 earthquake in L’Aquila, Central Italy". Environmental Hazards, 12(1): 60–73. https://doi.org/10.1080/17477891.2012.689250

Contreras D, Blaschke T, Kienberger S and Zeil P (2013). "Spatial connectivity as a recovery process indicator: The L’aquila earthquake". Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 80(9): 1782–803. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2012.12.001

ICNZ (2018). "ICNZ Submission on the Building Amendment Bill". Insurance Council of New Zealand, Wellington, 12 pp. https://www.icnz.org.nz/fileadmin/Assets/Submissions/ICNZ_submission_on_Building_Amendment_Bill_-_251018.pdf

Mcbride SK (2017). "The Canterbury Tales: An Insider’s Lessons and Reflections from the Canterbury Earthquake Sequence to Inform Better Communication Models". PhD Dissertation, Massey University, Wellington, New Zealand, 464 pp. https://mro.massey.ac.nz/handle/10179/11847

Potter SH, Becker JS, Johnston DM and Rossiter KP (2015). "An overview of the impacts of the 2010-2011 Canterbury earthquakes". International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 14(1): 6–14. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijdrr.2015.01.014

Hegarty P (2011). "Canterbury Earthquake - Police Response". Christchurch, 69 pp.

Dally J. Quake expert praises CBD cordon. The Press, 3 September 2012. http://www.stuff.co.nz/the-press/news/christchurch-earthquake-2011/7601420/Quake-expert-praises-CBD-cordon (Accessed 21/06/2019).

Platt S (2012). "Reconstruction in New Zealand Post 2010-11 Christchurch Earthquakes". Cambridge Archiectural Research Ltd., Cambridge, 72 pp. https://www.carltd.com/sites/carwebsite/files/Reconstruction%20New%20Zealand%20Post%202010-11%20Christchurch%20Earthquakes_0.pdf

Galloway BD and Hare HJ (2012). "A review of post-earthquake building control policies with respect to the recovery of the christchurch CBD". Bulletin of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering, 45(3): 105–116. https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.45.3.105-116

Comerio M, Elwood K, Mayes R, Berkowitz R, Bruneau M, Dismuke J, Gavin H, Jaiswal K, Kirsch T, Lai T, Marshall J, Mayes R, Mitrani-Reiser J, Morgan T, Mote T, Peek L, Sritharan S, Sutton J, Turner F, Wein A, Yashinsky M and O’Rourke T (2011). "EERI Special Earthquake Report - Learning from Earthquakes". EERI, Oakland, 16 pp. https://www.eeri.org/site/images/eeri_newsletter/2011_pdf/EERI_NewZealand_EQRpt_web.pdf

Taylor JE, Chang SE, Elwood KJ, Seville E and Brunsdon D (2012). "Learning from Christchurch : Technical Decisions and Societal Consequences in Post-Earthquake Recovery". Resilient Organisations, Christchurch, 38 pp. https://www.resorgs.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/critical_decisions_in_the_recovery_of_christchurch.pdf

McLean I, Oughton D, Ellis S, Wakelin B and Rubin CB (2012). "Review of the Civil Defence Emergency Management Response to the 22 February Christchurch Earthquake". Ian Mclean Consultancy Services Ltd., Roturua, 243 pp. https://www.civildefence.govt.nz/assets/Uploads/publications/Review-CDEM-Response-22-February-Christchurch-Earthquake.pdf

Hamling IJ, Hreinsdóttir S, Clark K, Elliott J, Liang C, Litchfield N, Villamor P, Wallace L, Wright TJ, D’Anastasio E, Bannister S, Burbidge D, Denys P, Gentle P, Howarth J, Mueller C, Palmer N, Pearson C, Power W, Barnes P, Barrell DJA, Van Dissen R, Langridge R, Little T, Nicol A, Pettinga J, Rowland J and Stirling M (2017). "Complex multifault rupture during the 2016 M w 7.8 Kaikōura earthquake, New Zealand". American Association for the Advancement of Science, 356(6334). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aam7194

Fleisher S (2019). "Wellington City’s emergency management response to the November 2016 Kaikōura earthquake". Australasian Journal of Disaster and Trauma Studies, 23 (2). http://trauma.massey.ac.nz/issues/2019-2/AJDTS_23_2_Fleisher.pdf

Giovinazzi S, Austin A, Ruiter R, Foster C, Nayyerloo M, Nair N and Wotherspoon LM (2017). “Resilience and fragility of the telecommunication network to seismic events: evidence after the Kaikōura [New Zealand] earthquake sequence”. Bulletin of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering, 50(2): 318-328. https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.50.2.318-328

Hughes MW, Nayyerloo M, Bellagamba X, Morris J, Brabhaharan P, Rooney S, Hobbs E, Wooley K and Hutchison S (2017). “Impacts of the 14th November 2016 Kaikōura earthquake on three waters systems in Wellington, Marlborough and Kaikōura, New Zealand: Preliminary observations”. Bulletin of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering, 50(2): 306-317. http://hdl.handle.net/10092/14685

MBIE (2019). "Managing Buildings in an Emergency". Ministry of Business Innovation and Employment, Wellington, 136 pp. https://www.building.govt.nz/managing-buildings/managing-buildings-in-an-emergency/

Wibawa T. Indonesia tsunami: Palu residents turn to looting as desperation grows. ABC news, 2 October 2018. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-10-02/indonesia-earthquake-tsunami-palu-residents-looting-death-toll/10328882 (Accessed 25/06/2019)

Sherwell P and Sawer P. Haiti earthquake: looting and gun-fights break out. The Telegraph, 20 January 2010. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/centralamericaandthecaribbean/haiti/7005554/Haiti-earthquake-looting-and-gun-fights-break-out.html (Accessed 24/06/2019).

Gillies A and Leask A. Christchurch earthquake: Looters to have day in court. NZ Herald, 12 September 2010. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10672793 (Accessed 25/06/2019).

Haapala, A (2003). "The Urban Identity: The City as a Place to Dwell". in Place and Location III. Estonian Academy of Arts, Tallinn, 12 pp. http://www.eki.ee/km/place/pdf/kp3_01_Haapala.pdf

Lynch K (1960). "The Image of the City". MIT Press, Cambridge. 103 pp. http://www.miguelangelmartinez.net/IMG/pdf/1960_Kevin_Lynch_The_Image_of_The_City_book.pdf

Stuff. Angry cordon jumpers seek talks.the press, 21 March 2011. http://www.stuff.co.nz/the-press/4791575/Angry-cordon-jumpers-seek-talks (Accessed 29/06/2019).

Kanarev N (1996). "Legal issues associated with evacuation: a theoretical perspective". Australian Journal of Emergency Management, 11(2): 41–6. https://search.informit.com.au/documentSummary;dn=398074205173350;res=IELAPA

CALBO (2013). "CALBO’s Interim Guidance for Barricading, Cordoning, Emergency Evaluation and Stabilization of Buildings with Substantial Damage in Disasters". California Building Officials, California, 2 pp. https://www.calbo.org/sites/main/files/file-attachments/guidanceforbuildingswithsubstantialdamageindisasterspublishedjuly2015.pdf?1525122335 (Accessed 18/05/2019).

Stevenson JR, Kachali H, Whitman Z, Seville E, Vargo J and Wilson T (2011). "Preliminary observations of the impacts the 22 February Christchurch earthquake had on organisations and the economy: A Report from the Field [22 February-22 March 2011]". Bulletin of New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering, 44(2): 65. https://www.nzsee.org.nz/db/Bulletin/Archive/44(2)0065.pdf

CERA (2016). "Cordon access for property owners, tenants and residents". Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Authority, Christchurch, 3 pp. https://quakestudies.canterbury.ac.nz/store/object/524726

Published
2021-03-01
How to Cite
Shrestha, S., Orchiston, C., Elwood, K., Johnston, D., & Becker, J. (2021). To cordon or not to cordon: The inherent complexities of post-earthquake cordoning learned from Christchurch and Wellington experiences . Bulletin of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering, 54(1), 40-48. https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.54.1.40-48
Section
Articles

Most read articles by the same author(s)