From brittle to ductile
75 years of seismic design in New Zealand
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.39.3.158-169Abstract
This paper traces the development of seismic structural design in New Zealand since the 1931 Hawke’s Bay Earthquake, with emphasis on reinforced concrete buildings. From the mainly rigid and brittle unreinforced masonry structures which behaved so poorly in the 1931 earthquake through the development of flexible ductile seismic design and base (seismic) isolation of the 60’s to 80’s to today where the structural engineer is expected to design and construct a building which will not only remain standing with little damage but will be operational a short time after the major earthquake. In some ways the structural design aims and objectives have turned full circle in the intervening 75 years. We have gone from brittle rigid structures through a period where flexibility was paramount to now where flexibility is limited and greater lateral stiffnesses are required, but with ductile elements in the structure. This paper traces the efforts of New Zealand’s pre-eminent structural engineers and scientists to make seismic design techniques world leading. In most facets they have been successful (in my view) but as I will say more than once, only time will tell!
References
American Concrete Institute, ACI 318-63 (1963). “Building Code Requirements for Reinforced Concrete”, ACI, Detroit, 144p.
Blakeley, R.W.G., Charleson, A.W., Hitchcock, H.C., Megget, L.M., Priestley, M.J.N., Sharpe, R.D. and Skinner, R.I. (1979), “Recommendations for the design and construction of base isolated structures”, Bulletin NZNSEE, 12 (2), June, 136-157.
Blakeley, R.W.G., Megget, L.M. & Priestley, M.J.N. (1977). “Seismic performance of two full-size reinforced concrete beam-column joint units”, Bulletin NZNSEE, 8 (1), March, 38-69.
Blume, J.A., Newmark, N.M. and Corning, L.H. (1961). Design of multi-storey reinforced concrete buildings for earthquake motions, Portland Cement Association, Illinois.
Brooke, N., Megget, L., Fenwick, R. and Ingham, J., (2004). “Bond strength of reinforced concrete beam-column joints incorporating 500 MPa reinforcement”, SESOC Journal, 17 (2), September, 37-46.
Crookes, S. Irwin (1940). Structural Design of Earthquake-Resistant Buildings, Leightons Ltd., Auckland, New Zealand, 209p.
Cull, J.E.L. (Chairman) (1931). Report of the Building Regulations Committee, Report to New Zealand House of Representatives, H-21.
Davenport, P.N. (2004). “Review of seismic provisions of historic New Zealand loading codes”, NZSEE Technical Conference and AGM, Rotorua, 19-21, March, 10p.
de Montalk, R.W. (1932). Shock absorbing or minimizing means for buildings, US Patent 1847820.
“Edgecumbe revisited” (1987), “Review of the special session at the Pacific Conference on Earthquake Engineering”, NZ Engineering, 42 (8), September, 41.
Fenwick, R.C., Davidson, B.J. and Chung, B.T. (1992). “P-Delta actions in seismic resistant structures”, Bull. NZNSEE, 25 (1), March, 56-69.
Fenwick, R.C., Lau, D. and Davidson, B.J. (2002). “A comparison of the seismic design requirements in the New Zealand Loadings Standard with other major design codes”, Bulletin NZSEE, 35 (3), September, 190-203. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.35.3.190-203
Fenwick, R.C. and Megget, L.M. (1993). “Elongation and load deflection characteristics of reinforced concrete members containing plastic hinges”, Bulletin NZNSEE, 26 (1), March, 28-41. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.26.1.28-41
Ford, C.R. (1926). Earthquakes and Building Construction, Whitcombe and Tombs Ltd., Auckland. 113p.
Fowler, Michael, (1983). “The seismic upgrading of buildings – its effect upon Wellington City”, NZ Engineering, 38 (10), November, 30-34.
Hollings, J.P. (1968a). “Reinforced Concrete Seismic Design”, Bulletin of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering, 2 (3), 217-250, September.
Hollings, J.P. (1968b). “A reinforced concrete building in Wellington”, Bulletin NZSEE, 2 (4), December, 420-442.
J.A.R.J. 1963. “Earthquake Engineering in N.Z.”, Leading Article, New Zealand Engineering, New Zealand Institution of Engineers, 18 (9), September 15, 305.
Matthews, J.G., Bull, D.K. and Mander, J.M. (2003). “Preliminary results from the testing of a hollowcore floor slab building”, Proceedings NZSEE Pacific Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Christchurch, 9p.
Megget, L.M. (1978). “Analysis and design of a base-isolated reinforced concrete frame building”, Bulletin NZNSEE, 11 (4), December, 245-254.
Megget, L.M. & Park, R. (1971). “Reinforced concrete exterior beam-column joints under seismic loading”, New Zealand Engineering, 26 (11), November, 341-353.
New Zealand Standard NZSS 1900, Chap. 9.3 (1964). “New Zealand Standard Model Bylaw, Design and Construction, Concrete”, New Zealand Standards Institute, 60p.
New Zealand Standard NZS 3101 (1982). “Code of Practice for The Design of Concrete Structures”, Standards Association of New Zealand, Part 1 and part 2 (Commentary).
NZNSEE Discussion Group (1977). “Seismic design of ductile moment resisting reinforced concrete frames”, Bulletin NZNSEE, sections A, E, F, G, H and K in 10 (2), 69-105, sections C and J in 10 (4), 219-237 and Section D in 11(2), 121-128.
NZNSEE Discussion Group (1980). “Seismic design of reinforced concrete walls and diaphragms”, Bulletin NZNSEE, sections A, B, C, D, F and G in 13 (2), June, 103-193.
NZS 4203 (1992). “Code of practice for General Structural Design and Design Loadings for Buildings”, Standards New Zealand, 134p.
NZS1170.5 (2004). “Structural Design Actions, part 5: Earthquake Actions – New Zealand”, Standards New Zealand.
NZSS No. 95 (1935). “New Zealand Standard Model Building By-Law, sections I to X”, New Zealand Standards Institute, Wellington.
NZSS No. 95 (1955). “New Zealand Standard Model Building By-Law”, New Zealand Standards Institute, Wellington.
NZSS 1900 Chapter 8 (1965). “New Zealand Standard Model Building Bylaw, Basic Design Loads”, New Zealand Standards Institute, Wellington, 39p.
O’Driscoll, R.J. and Shepherd, R. (1963). “Dynamic Response of Multi-story Buildings”, New Zealand Engineering, Journal of NZIE, 18 (9), 307-312.
Office of the Chief Structural Engineer, (1970). “Code of Practice Design of Public Buildings, PW 81/10/1”, Ministry of Works, New Zealand, 39p + app.
Park, Robert (1987). “Development of structural design procedures for earthquake resistance in New Zealand”, Transactions Institution of Professional Engineers New Zealand, IPENZ, 14, 1/CE, March, 22-32.
Park, R. (1968). “Ductility of reinforced concrete frames under seismic loading”, N.Z. Engineering, 23(11), November, 427-435.
Park, R. and Paulay, T. (1975). Reinforced Concrete Structures, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 769p. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470172834
Park, R., Priestley, M.J.N., Gill, W.D. and Potangaroa, R.T. (1980). “Ductility and strength of reinforced concrete columns with spirals and hoops under seismic loading”, Proceedings 7th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Vol. 7, Istanbul, 15-22.
Park, R. & Thompson, K.J. (1976). “Some recent research in New Zealand into aspects of the seismic resistance of prestressed concrete frames”, Bulletin NZNSEE, 9 (3), September, 167-174.
Seismology Committee of the Structural Engineers’ Association of California (1963). “Recommended lateral force requirements”, SEAOC, San Francisco.
Shepherd, R. (1969). “New Zealand Earthquake Engineering Education”, Bulletin NZSEE, 2 (3), September, 200-201.
Skinner, R.I. 1963. “Earthquake-resistant Design of Buildings: Research Problems”, New Zealand Engineering, Journal of NZIE, 18 (9), 313-315.
Skinner, R.I., Tyler, R.G., Heine, A.J. and Robinson, W.H. (1980). “Hysteretic dampers for the protection of structures from earthquakes”, Bulletin NZNSEE, 13 (1), March, 22-36.
Standards New Zealand NZS 3101 (1995). “Concrete Structures Standard, Part 1 –The Design of Concrete Structures and Part 2 Commentary”, Standards New Zealand.
van de Vorstenbosch, G., Charleson, A.W. and Dowrick, D.J. (2002). “Reinforced concrete building performance in the Mw 7.8 1931 Hawke’s Bay , New Zealand, earthquake”, Bulletin NZSEE, 35 (3), September, 149-164.
