Integrated Wellington region land transport resilience study
Wellington region’s transport network has poor resilience to natural hazards, given the rugged terrain, high seismicity and wet climate. This exposes the land access to the region and the capital city to be potentially cut off from the rest of New Zealand for several months, and its cities to be isolated from each other.
This paper reports on a pioneering integrated resilience study of the entire land transport system in the region provided by the state highways, principal and arterial local roads and the railway system. The study considered resilience risks from a range of natural hazards (earthquake, storm and tsunami) using the metrics of availability and outage. The resilience risks and the relative importance of the routes were used to assess the criticality of these risks for future investment in resilience enhancement. The criticality also considered risks to other lifeline utilities - power, water and telecommunications that share these transport corridors. The combined criticality was used to prioritise these resilience risks. The highest criticality resilience risks were classified into extreme, very high and high levels. The extreme criticality risks identified were the state highway between Ngauranga and Petone and the adjacent Ngauranga interchange between the two State Highways 1 and 2, which together provide access between Wellington, Hutt and Porirua cities. A range of very high risks were identified across the region which included both state highways and local roads. This novel resilience study provided the basis for a subsequent business case for future investment to enhance the resilience of the region’s transport network.
CAE (1991). “Lifelines in Engineering - Wellington Case Study”. Centre for Advanced Engineering (CAE), University of Canterbury, Christchurch, NZ.
Brabhaharan P (2004). “Systematic management of the risks to transportation networks from natural hazards”. 2nd International Symposium on Transportation Network Reliability, 20-24 August, Christchurch, NZ.
Hodgkinson E and Brabhaharan P (2009). “Hutt Valley Road Network Risk Management Study”. Report No GER 2009/20, Parts 1 and 2. Opus International Consultants, Wellington, NZ.
Mason D and Brabhaharan P (2015). “Resilience of road transportation lifelines for Porirua District”. Institute of Public Works Engineers Australasia Conference, May, Rotorua, NZ.
Brabhaharan P (2010). “State Highway Resilience Study, Wellington Region”. Opus International Consultants Limited, Wellington, NZ.
Brabhaharan P and Mason D (2012). “Wellington Region Road Network Earthquake Resilience Study”. Report No GER 2012-21, Opus International Consultants, Wellington, NZ.
CAE (1997). “Risks and Realities: A Multi-disciplinary Approach to the Vulnerability of Lifelines to Natural Hazards, based on the Work of the Christchurch Engineering Lifelines Group”. Centre for Advanced Engineering (CAE), University of Canterbury, Christchurch, NZ, 312pp.
Speed J and Brabhaharan P (2006). “Western Bay of Plenty road network risk assessment”. New Zealand Geotechnical Society 2006 Symposium on Earthquakes and Urban Development, 17-18 February, Nelson, New Zealand.
Brabhaharan P (2002). “Natural hazard risk management for road networks: Strategies for implementation”. Ingenium – Annual Conference 2002. 14-16 June, Queenstown, NZ.
Brabhaharan P, Fleming MJ and Lynch R (2001). “Natural Hazard Risk Management for Road Networks. Part I: Risk Management Strategies”. Transfund NZ Research Report 217, Opus International Consultants, Wellington, NZ, 75pp.
Brabhaharan P and Moynihan S (2002). “Natural Hazard Risk Management for Road Networks. Part II: Implementation Strategies”. Transfund New Zealand Research Report 212, Opus International Consultants, Wellington, NZ, 75pp.
Brabhaharan P, Wiles LM and Frietag S (2006). “Natural Hazard Road Risk Management Part III: Performance Criteria”. Land Transport New Zealand Research Report 296, Opus International Consultants, Wellington, NZ, 117pp.
Brabhaharan P (2006). “Recent advances in improving the resilience of road networks”. Remembering Napier 1931 – Building on 75 Years of Earthquake Engineering in New Zealand. Annual Conference of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering. 10-12 March, Napier, NZ.
Arumugam S and Brabhaharan P (2016). “Seismic and safety performance assessment and strengthening of tunnels in Wellington”. New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering Annual Conference, 1-3 April, Christchurch, NZ.
Mason D and Brabhaharan P (2013). “Resilience of transportation lifelines in the greater Wellington area”. 19th New Zealand Geotechnical Society Symposium, November, Queenstown, NZ.
NZTA (2016). “Strategic Case for Resilience - Wellington”. New Zealand Transport Agency (NZTA), Wellington, NZ.
Wellington Regional Council (1995). “Seismic Hazard Map Series: Slope Failure Hazard Maps”. Compiled from Works Consultancy Services Reports, Wellington, NZ.
Brabhaharan P, Jennings DN and McMinn JA (1993). “Liquefaction Hazard Study, Wellington Region”. Works Consultancy Services, Wellington, NZ.
Brabhaharan P (1994). “Assessment and mapping of earthquake induced liquefaction hazards in the Wellington Region, New Zealand”. First ANZ Young Geotechnical Professionals Conference, February 9-12, Sydney, Australia.
Yu J, Yong P, Reid S, Brabhaharan P and Meng P (2009). “The Ms 8.0 Wenchuan earthquake of 12 May 2008 reconnaissance report”. Bulletin of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering, 43(1): 41-83. https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.43.1.41-83 DOI: https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.43.1.41-83
Mason D and Brabhaharan P (2019). “Resilience of transport corridors in the 2016 Kaikōura earthquake, to inform recovery and future slope design and landslide hazard management”. Second International Conference on Natural Hazards & Infrastructure, 23-26 June, Chania, Greece. 9pp.