Seismic performance of reinforced concrete buildings in the 22 February Christchurch (Lyttelton) earthquake
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.44.4.239-278Abstract
Six months after the 4 September 2010 Mw 7.1 Darfield (Canterbury) earthquake, a Mw 6.2 Christchurch (Lyttelton) aftershock struck Christchurch on the 22 February 2011. This earthquake was centred approximately 10km south-east of the Christchurch CBD at a shallow depth of 5km, resulting in intense seismic shaking within the Christchurch central business district (CBD). Unlike the 4 Sept earthquake when limited-to-moderate damage was observed in engineered reinforced concrete (RC) buildings [35], in the 22 February event a high number of RC Buildings in the Christchurch CBD (16.2 % out of 833) were severely damaged. There were 182 fatalities, 135 of which were the unfortunate consequences of the complete collapse of two mid-rise RC buildings.
This paper describes immediate observations of damage to RC buildings in the 22 February 2011 Christchurch earthquake. Some preliminary lessons are highlighted and discussed in light of the observed performance of the RC building stock. Damage statistics and typical damage patterns are presented for various configurations and lateral resisting systems. Data was collated predominantly from first-hand post-earthquake reconnaissance observations by the authors, complemented with detailed assessment of the structural drawings of critical buildings and the observed behaviour.
Overall, the 22 February 2011 Mw 6.2 Christchurch earthquake was a particularly severe test for both modern seismically-designed and existing non-ductile RC buildings. The sequence of earthquakes since the 4 Sept 2010, particularly the 22 Feb event has confirmed old lessons and brought to life new critical ones, highlighting some urgent action required to remedy structural deficiencies in both existing and “modern” buildings. Given the major social and economic impact of the earthquakes to a country with strong seismic engineering tradition, no doubt some aspects of the seismic design will be improved based on the lessons from Christchurch. The bar needs to and can be raised, starting with a strong endorsement of new damage-resisting, whilst cost-efficient, technologies as well as the strict enforcement, including financial incentives, of active policies for the seismic retrofit of existing buildings at a national scale.
References
(EAG), E. A. G. (2011). Guidance on detailed engineering evaluation of earthquake affected non-residential buildings in Canterbury. Part 2 - Evaluation Procedure. Revision 5 19 July 2011. , Structural Engineering Society New Zealand (SESOC), Christchurch.
Al-Chaar, G., K., Issa, M. A., and Sweeney, S. (2002). "Behaviour of masonry-infilled nonductile reinforced concrete frames." ASCE J. of Struct. Eng., 128(8), 1055-1063. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9445(2002)128:8(1055)
Alavi, B., and Krawinkler, H. (2001). Effects of near-fault ground motions on frame structures. Report No.138 on CUREe-Kajima Phase III, The John A. Blume Earthquake Eng. Center, Stanford Uni., Stanford, CA.
Baird, A., Palermo, A., and Pampanin, S. (2011). "Facade damage assessment of multi-storey buildings in the 2011 Christchurch earthquake." Bull. of New Zealand Soc. of Earthquake Eng., (in press). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/suco.201100040
Beca (2011). Investigation into the collapse of the Pyne Gould Corporation building on 22nd February 2011. A report to the Department of Building and Housing (DBH). Beca Carter Hollings & Ferner Ltd., Auckland, New Zealand.
Berrill, J. (2011). "Some Aspects of the M6.3 February 22nd Earthquake." The PressChristchurch, 4.
Bertero, V. V., Mahin, S. A., and Herrera, R. A. (1978). "A seismic design implications of near-fault San Fernando earthquake record." Earthquake Eng. & Struct. Dyn., 6(1), 21-42. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/eqe.4290060105
Boys, A., Bull, D. K., and Pampanin, S. "Seismic performance of concrete columns with inadequate transverse reinforcements." Proc., New Zealand Concrete Society (NZCS) Conference 2009, 12.
Bradley, B., and Cubrinovski, M. (2011). "Near-source strong ground motions observed in the 22 February 2011 Christchurch earthquake" Seismological Research Letters, 82(6), 853-865. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1785/gssrl.82.6.853
Buchanan, A., Bull, D. K., Dhakal, R. P., MacRae, G. A., Palermo, A., and Pampanin, S. (2011). Base isolation and damage-resistant technologies for improved seismic performance of buildings. A submission to the Canterbury Earthquakes Royal Commission., University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Bull, D. K. (2011). "Stairs and Access Ramps between Floors in Multi-storey Buildings. A report o the Canterbury Earthquakes Royal Commission.", Holmes Consulting Group, Christchurch, N.Z., 8.
Choi, H., Saiidi, M. S., Somerville, P., and El-Azazy, S. (2010). "Experimental study of reinforced concrete bridge columns subjected to near-fault ground motions." ACI Structural Journal, 107(1), 3-12. DOI: https://doi.org/10.14359/51663383
Cousins, J., and McVerry, G. H. (2010). "Overview of strong motion data from the Darfield earthquake." Bull. of New Zealand Soc. of Earthquake Eng., 43(4), 222-227`. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.43.4.222-227
Davenport, P. N. "Review of seismic provisions of historic New Zealand loading codes." Proc., NZSEE 2004 Conf., NZSEE, 10.
DBH (2005). Practice Advisory 3: Beware of limitations of cold-worked wire mesh, Dept. of Building and Housing (DBH), Wellington, NZ.
DBH (2011). Information sheet on seismicity changes - Structure B1/VM1, B1/AS1, B1/AS3 Dept. of Building and Housing (DBH), Wellington, NZ.
DBH (2011). Practice Advisory 13: Egress Stairs: Earthquake checks needed for some, Dept. of Building and Housing (DBH), Wellington, NZ.
DBH (2011). Structural performance of Christchurch CBD Buildings in the 22 February 2011 aftershock. Stage 1 Expert Panel Report., Department of Building and Housing (DBH), Auckland, New Zealand.
Dunning Thornton (2011). Report on the structural performance of the Hotel Grand Chancellor in the earthquake on 22 February 2011. A report to the Department of Building and Housing (DBH). Dunning Thornton Consultants Ltd., Wellington, New Zealand.
Fenwick, R., Bull, D. K., and Gardiner, D. (2010). Assessment of hollow-core floors for seismic performance. Research report 2010-02., Dept. of Civil and Natural Resources Eng., Uni. of Canterbury, Christchurch, NZ.
Fenwick, R., and MacRae, G. A. (2009). "Comparison of New Zealand Standards used for seismic design of concrete buildings." Bull. of New Zealand Soc. of Earthquake Eng., 42(3), 187-203. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.42.3.187-203
Fry, B., Benites, R., and Kaiser, A. (2011). "The character of accelerations in the Christchurch Mw 6.3 earthquake." Seismological Research Letters, submitted. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1785/gssrl.82.6.846
Galloway, B., Hare, J., and Bull, D. K. "Performance of multi-storey reinforced concrete buildings in the Darfield earthquake." Proc., 9th Pacific Conf. on Earthquake Eng., 11.
Gavin, H., and Wilkinson, G. (2010). "Preliminary observations of the effect of the 2010 Darfield earthquake on the base-isolated Christchurch Women's Hospital." Bull. of New Zealand Soc. of Earthquake Eng., 43(4), 360-368. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.43.4.360-367
Gerstenberger, M. C., McVerry, G. H., Rhoades, D. A., Stirling, M., Berryman, K., and Webb, T. (2011). Update of the Z-factor for Christchurch considering earthquake clustering following the Darfield earthquake. GNS Science Report 2011/29. , GNS Science, Lower Hutt, N.Z.
Giorgini, S., Taylor, M., Cubrinovski, M., and Pampanin, S. "Preliminary observations of multi-storey RC building foundation performance in Christchurch following the 22nd February 2011 Earthquake." Proc., NZ Concrete Industry Conference 2011, New Zealand Concrete Society (NZCS).
GNS (2011). Canterbury earthquakes sequence and implications for seismic design levels. A submission to the Canterbury Earthquakes Royal Commission., Geological Nuclear Science (GNS), Lower Hutt, New Zealand.
GNS (2011). "February 22nd aftershock: Christchurch Central Business District spectra." <http://www.gns.cri.nz/gns/NHRP/Hazard-themes/Geological-Hazards/February-22nd-aftershock/Christchurch-Central-Business-District-Spectra>. (1 Nov, 2011).
Hall, J. F., Heaton, T. H., Halling, M. W., and Wald, D. J. (1995). "Near-source ground motion and its effects on flexible buildings." Earthquake Spectra, 11(4), 569-605. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1193/1.1585828
Hare, J. (2009). Heritage earthquake prone building strengthening cost study. Prepared for Christchurch City Council. (Internal report). Holmes Consulting Group, Christchurch, NZ.
Heather, B. (2011). "Life ebbing for heritage buildings." <http://www.stuff.co.nz/the-press/news/christchurch-earthquake-2011/5111994/Life-ebbing-for-heritage-buildings>. (08/06/2011, 2011).
Henry, R., and Ingham, J. M. (2011). "Behaviour of tilt-up precast concrete buildings during the recent Canterbury Earthquakes in New Zealand." Structural Concrete, (in press). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/suco.201100035
Holmes, I. L. "Concrete masonry buildings in New Zealand." Proc., 3rd World Conf. on Earthquake Eng., 244-255.
Kam, W. Y., and Pampanin, S. (2011). General performance of buildings in Christchurch CBD: A contextual report prepared for DBH Expert Panel. , University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Kam, W. Y., Pampanin, S., Dhakal, R. P., Gavin, H., and Roeder, C. W. (2010). "Seismic performance of reinforced concrete buildings in the September 2010 Darfield (Canterbury) earthquakes." Bull. of New Zealand Soc. of Earthquake Eng., 43(4), 340-350. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.43.4.340-350
Kam, W. Y., Pampanin, S., Palermo, A., and Carr, A. (2010). "Self-centering structural systems with combination of hysteretic and viscous energy dissipations." Earthquake Eng. & Struct. Dyn., 39(10), 1083-1108. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/eqe.983
MacRae, G. A., Morrow, D. V., and Roeder, C. W. (2001). "Near-fault ground motion effects on simple structures." J. of Earthquake Eng., 127(9), 996-1004. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9445(2001)127:9(996)
Marshall, J. (2011). "Recommendations for precast concrete hollowcore ramp." Stalhton New Zealand, Auckland, N.Z.
Matthews, J., Bull, D. K., and Mander, J. B. "Hollowcore floor slab performance following a severe earthquake." Proc., Concrete Structures in Seismic Region: fib 2003 Symposium.
McVerry, G. H., Zhao, J. X., Abrahamson, N. A., and Somerville, P. (2006). "New Zealand acceleration response spectrum attenuation relations for crustal and subduction zone earthquakes." Bull. of New Zealand Soc. of Earthquake Eng., 39(1), 1-58. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.39.1.1-58
NZS1170 (2004). NZS 1170.5:2004 Structural design actions. Part 5: Earthquake actions - New Zealand., Standards New Zealand, Wellington, NZ.
NZS1170 (2004). NZS 1170:2004 Structural design actions, Standards New Zealand, Wellington, NZ.
NZS1900.8-64 (1964). NZS1900 - Model building bylaw: Chapter 8: Basic Design Loads and Commentary. , Standards Assoc. of New Zealand, Wellington, NZ.
NZS1900.9-64 (1964). NZS1900 - Model building bylaw: Chapter 9.2: Design and construction - Masonry, Standards Assoc. of New Zealand, Wellington, NZ.
NZS3101:1970P (1970). Code of practice for the design of concrete structures NZS 3101:1970 (Provisional), Standards Assoc. of New Zealand, Wellington, NZ.
NZS3101:1982 (1982). Code of practice for the design of concrete structures NZS 3101:1982, Standards Assoc. of New Zealand, Wellington, NZ.
NZS3101:1995 (2004). Amendments No.3 to 1995 Standard (NZS3101), Standards New Zealand, Wellington, NZ.
NZS3101:2006 (2006). NZS 3101:2006 Concrete structures standard, Standards New Zealand, Wellington, NZ.
NZS4203:1976 (1976). Code of practice for general structural design and design loading for buildings. NZS 4203:1976, Standards Assoc. of New Zealand, Wellington, NZ.
NZS4203:1984 (1984). Code of practice for general structural design and design loading for buildings. NZS 4203:1984, Standards Assoc. of New Zealand, Wellington, NZ.
NZS4230:2004 (2006). NZS 4230:2004 Design of reinforced concrete masonry structures, Standards New Zealand, Wellington, NZ.
NZSEE (2006). Assessment and improvement of the structural performance of buildings in earthquakes, New Zealand Soc. for Earthquake Eng. (NZSEE), Wellington, NZ.
NZSEE (2009). Building safety evaluation during a state of emergency. Guidelines for territorial authorities. 2nd ed., New Zealand Soc. for Earthquake Eng. (NZSEE), Wellington, NZ.
Pampanin, S. (2006). "Controversial aspects in seismic assessment and retrofit of structures in modern times: Understanding and implementing lessons from ancient heritage." Bull. of New Zealand Soc. of Earthquake Eng., 39(2), 120-133. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.39.2.120-133
Pampanin, S. (2009). "Alternative performance-based retrofit strategies and solutions for existing RC buildings. Geotechnical, Geological and Earthquake Eng. vol. 10." Seismic Risk Assessment and Retrofitting With Special Emphasis on Existing Low Rise Structures, A. Ilki, F. Karadogan, S. Pala, and E. Yuksel, eds., Springer, Netherlands, 267-295.
Pampanin, S., and Kam, W. Y. (2011). "Seismic performance of reinforced concrete buildings during the 22nd February 2011 Christchurch earthquakes." Seminar notes for NZCS-NZSEE-SESOC NZTDS Building Performance in the February 2011 Christchurch Earthquake Seminar., New Zealand Concrete Society (NZCS), Auckland, N.Z., 130.
Pampanin, S., Kam, W. Y., Akguzel, U., Tasligedik, A. S., and Quintana-Gallo, P. (2011). Report on the observed earthquake damage of reinforced concrete buildings in the Christchurch CBD on the 22 February 2011 Earthquake. (draft in preparation), University of Canterbury, Christchurch, N.Z.
Pampanin, S., Kam, W. Y., Haverland, G., and Gardiner, S. "Seismic Performance of a Post-Tensioned Precast Concrete Building (PRESSS Technology) during the 22nd Feb 2011 Christchurch Earthquake: Reality Check meets Community Expectations‟." Proc., NZ Concrete Industry Conference 2011, New Zealand Concrete Society (NZCS).
Pampanin, S., Kam, W. Y., Tasligedik, A. S., Quintana-Gallo, P., and Akguzel, U. "Considerations on the seismic performance of pre-1970s RC buildings in the Christchurch CBD during the 4th Sept 2010 Canterbury earthquake: was that really a big one?" Proc., 9th Pacific Conf. on Earthquake Eng.
Park, R. (2002). "Seismic design and construction of precast concrete buildings in New Zealand." PCI Journal, 47(5), 60-75. DOI: https://doi.org/10.15554/pcij.09012002.60.75
Park, R. (2002). "A summary of result of simulated seismic load tests on reinforced concrete beam-column joints, beams and columns with substandard reinforcing details." J. of Earthquake Eng., 6(2), 147-174. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13632460209350413
Paulay, T. (1997). "Are existing seismic torsion provisions achieving the design aims?" Earthquake Spectra, 13(2), 259-279. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1193/1.1585945
Paulay, T., and Priestley, M. J. N. (1992). Seismic design of reinforced concrete and masonry buildings, John Wiley & Sons Inc., Christchurch, NZ. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470172841
Phan, V., Saiidi, M. S., Anderson, J., and Ghasemi, H. (2007). "Near-fault ground motion effects on reinforced concrete bridge columns." ASCE J. of Struct. Eng., 133(7), 982-989. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9445(2007)133:7(982)
Priestley, M. J. N., Calvi, G. M., and Kowalsky, M. J. (2007). Displacement-based seismic design of structures, IUSS Press, Pavia, Italy.
Quintana-Gallo, P., Akguzel, U., Pampanin, S., and Carr, A. "Shake table tests of non-ductile as-built and repaired RC frames." Proc., 9th Pacific Conf. on Earthquake Eng., NZSEE.
Restrepo, J., Conte, J. P., and Panagiotou, M. "The design and shake table testing of a full-scale 7-storey reinforced concrete cantilevered wall." Proc., NZSEE 2010 Conf., NZSEE.
Rosenblueth, E., and Meli, R. (1986). "The 1985 Earthquake: Causes and effects in Mexico City." Concrete International: Design & Construction, 8(5), 23-34.
Royal Commission (2011). Canterbury earthquakes Royal Commission interim report, Canterbury Earthquakes Royal Commissions Christchurch, N.Z.
Royal Commission (2011). "Canterbury Earthquakes Royal Commissions. Technical Reports. ." <http://canterbury.royalcommission.govt.nz/>. (1 Sept, 2011).
SEAOC (1995). Vision 2000 Committee Report - A framework for performance-based seismic engineering, Structural Engineers Association of California (SEAOC), Sacramento, CA.
SESOC (2011). Preliminary observations from Christchurch earthquakes., Structural Engineering Society New Zealand (SESOC), Auckland, N.Z.
Somerville, P. (2003). "Magnitude scaling of the near-fault rupture directivity pulse." Physics of the Earth and Planetary Interiors, 137(1), 201-212. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0031-9201(03)00015-3
Somerville, P. "Engineering characterization of near fault ground motions." Proc., NZSEE 2005 Conf., NZSEE.
Somerville, P., Smith, N. F., Graves, R. W., and Abrahamson, N. A. (1997). "Modification of empirical strong ground motion attenuation relations to include the amplitude and duration effects of rupture directivity." Seismological Research Letters, 68(1), 199-222. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1785/gssrl.68.1.199
Zhang, D., Fleischman, R., Naito, C. J., and Ren, R. (2010). "Experimental evaluation of pretopped precast diaphragm critical flexure joint under seismic demands." ASCE J. of Struct. Eng., 137(10), 1063-1074. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)ST.1943-541X.0000352
