Enhancing seismic regulatory compliance practices for non-structural elements in New Zealand
Most non-structural elements (NSEs) including ceilings, piping, services equipment and cladding systems, etc., are typically prone to failure in the event of relatively low to medium earthquake shakings. The poor performance of NSEs demonstrated in recent earthquake events in New Zealand has revealed a gap in NSE design and construction practices, especially regarding compliance with the NSE performance standard (NZS 4219:2009). This study sought to examine the NZ 4219:2009 and compliance in New Zealand’s construction industry, towards improving the performance of NSEs during earthquakes.
Using a face-to-face interview enquiry technique, findings from this study revealed that although majority of the participants consider the NZS 4219:2009 to be very important in improving the performance of NSEs during earthquakes, some shortcomings were also identified: (i) non-compliance with the NZ 4219:2009 by construction professionals; (ii) exclusion of guidelines for specific NSEs from the scope of the NZS 4219:2009; (iii) poor ease of use of the NZS 4219:2009 and other relevant excluded NSE guidelines; and (iv) lack of clarity in the NZS 4219:2009 regarding attribution of ultimate design responsibility for NSE seismic coordination.
As a recommendation, the establishment of a robust, simple-to-use seismic specification document that will provide one-stop specifications for the design and installation of NSEs could be a possible solution to promoting strong compliance practices within the New Zealand construction industry, towards achieving improved performance of NSEs during earthquakes.
Uma S and Beattie G (2010). “Seismic assessment of engineering systems in hospitals – a challenge for operational continuity”. Proceedings of the NZSEE Annual Conference, Wellington, Paper No 21.
Filiatrault A and Sullivan T (2014). “Performance-based seismic design of nonstructural building components: The next frontier of earthquake engineering”. Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration, 13(1): 17-46. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11803-014-0238-9
Elkink A (2015). Seismic Restraint of Building Services. http://www.buildmagazine.org.nz/articles/show/seismic-restraint-of-building-services (accessed 16/05/2017).
Lee TH, Kato M, Matsumiya T, Sugita K and Nakashima M (2007). “Seismic performance evaluation of non-structural components: drywall partitions”. Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics, 36(3): 367-382. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/eqe.638
Chock G, Robertson I, Nicholson P, Brandes H, Medley E, Okubo P and Linurna G (2006). “Compilation of Observations of the October 15, 2006 Kiholo Bay (Mw 6.7) and Mahukona (Mw 6.0) Earthquakes, Hawaii”. Earthquake Engineering Research Institute, 31pp.
Boroschek R and Retamales R (2001). “Damage Observed in El Salvador's Public Hospital System during the January 13, 2001 Earthquake”. WHO/PAHO Collaborating Center for Disaster Mitigation in Health Facilities, University of Chile, Santiago, Chile.
McGavin GL and Patrucco HA (1994). “Survey of Nonstructural Damage to Healthcare Facilities by the January 17, 1994 Northridge Earthquake”. HMC Group, Ontario, Canada.
Beattie GJ (2000). “The design of building services for earthquake resistance”. Proceedings of the of 12th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Auckland, NZ.
Dhakal RP, MacRae GA and Hogg K (2011). “Performance of ceilings in the February 2011 Christchurch earthquake”. Bulletin of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering, Christchurch Earthquake Special Issue, 43(4): 377-387.
Braga F, Manfredi V, Masi A, Salvatori A and Vona M (2011). “Performance of non-structural elements in RC buildings during the L’Aquila, 2009 earthquake”. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 9: 307-324.
Miranda E, Mosqueda G, Retamales R and Pekcan G (2012). “Performance of nonstructural components during the 27 February 2010 Chile earthquake”. Earthquake Spectra, 28(S1): S453-S471.
Ferner H, Wemyss M, Baird A, Beer A and Hunter D (2014). “Seismic performance of non-structural elements within buildings”. Proceedings of the NZSEE Annual Conference, Auckland, Paper No 69.
Taghavi S and Miranda E (2003). “Response Assessment of Non-structural Building Elements”. Report No. 2003/05. Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center, Richmond, CA.
Dhakal RP (2010). “Damage to Non-structural Components and Contents in the 2010 Darfield Earthquake”. Bulletin of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering, Darfield Earthquake Special Issue, 43(4): 404-411. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.43.4.404-411
ICNZ (2016). Failure to comply with standards a likely cause of Wellington commercial building damage. Media Centre. http://www.icnz.org.nz/category/press-release/ (accessed 17/05/2017).
Banks G and Dunbar A (2015). “Seismic design of interior overhead non-structural elements”. Proceedings of the NZSEE Annual Conference, Rotorua, Paper No 70.
Ferner H, Lander M, Douglas G, Baird A, Wemyss M and Hunter D (2016). “Pragmatic Improvements to Seismic Resilience of Non-Structural Elements –Practitioners Perspective”. Bulletin of the New Zealand National Society for Earthquake Engineering, 49(1): 22-33. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.49.1.22-33
FEMA (2015). “Reducing the Risks of Nonstructural Earthquake Damage. A Practical Guide - FEMA E-74”. Federal Emergency Management Agency. Washington, DC.
SNZ (2009). “NZS 4219:2009: Seismic Performance of Engineering Systems in Buildings”. Standards New Zealand, Wellington, NZ.
Welch DP, Sullivan TJ and Filiatrault A (2014). “Potential of Building Information Modelling for Seismic Risk Mitigation in Buildings”. Bulletin of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering, 47(4): 253-263. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5459/bnzsee.47.4.253-263
Egbelakin T, Wilkinson S, Potangaroa R and Ingham J (2013). “Improving regulatory frameworks for earthquake risk mitigation”. Building Research and Information, 41(6): 677-689. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09613218.2013.819546
MBIE (2016). Building Regulatory Framework: Building Performance. Ministry of Business Innovation & Employment, Wellington, New Zealand. Retrieved from file:///C:/Users/eyakubu/Downloads/nz-regulatoryframework-2868%20(2).pdf (accessed 15/05/2017).
MBIE (2016). Practice Advisory 19: Improving Earthquake Performance of Non-structural Elements (978-0-947524-81-4). Ministry of Business Innovation and Employment, Wellington, New Zealand. Retrieved from https://www.building.govt.nz/assets/_generated_pdfs/practice-advisory-19-4189-all.pdf. (accessed 15/05/2017).
Shelton RH (2009). Revised Seismic Standard for Building Services. http://www.buildmagazine.org.nz/assets/PDF/B111-60ResearchSeismic.pdf (accessed 08/11/2016).
Masek J and Ridge R (2009). “Identification of Methods to Achieve Successful Implementation of Nonstructural and Equipment Seismic Restraints”. Earthquake Engineering Research Institute, Oakland, CA.
SNZ (2016). “NZS 1170.5:2004 - Structural Design Actions Part 5, Earthquake Actions - Amendment 1”. Standards New Zealand, Wellington, NZ.
BRANZ (2015). Non-Structural Components: Seismic Resilient Non-Structural Element Fact Sheet. Building Research Association of NZ. http://www.branz.co.nz/nonstructural (accessed 17/12/2016).
Kvale S (1983). “The qualitative research interview: A phenomenological and a hermeneutical mode of understanding”. Journal of phenomenological psychology, 14(2): 171-182. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/156916283X00090
Maxwell JA (2012). “Qualitative Research Design: An Interactive Approach”. Sage Publications, London.
Babbie ER (2013). “The Basics of Social Research”. Sixth Edition, Cengage Learning, Wadsworth, USA.
Easterby-Smith M, Thorpe R and Jackson PR (2012). “Management Research”. Sage Publications, London.
Neuman LW (2014). “Social Research Methods: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches”. Seventh Edition, Pearson Education Limited: Essex, England.
CCCA (2014). Seismic Process Guide for Mechanical Services Subcontractors. http://www.irhace.org.nz/uploads/Seismic%20Process%20Guide%20for%20Mechanical%20Services%20Subcontractors%20October%202014.pdf (accessed 15/05/2017).
AWCINZ (2015). Code of Practice for Design, Installation and Seismic Restraint of Suspended Ceilings. http://awci.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/AWCICoP-Web.pdf (accessed 15/05/2017).
Copyright (c) 2018 Temitope Egbelakin, Itohan E. Yakubu, Justin Bowden
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.